Sorry Fred, but Henry came first - A few facts regarding aboriginal hockey players


James Milks

Sorry Fred, but Henry came first - A few facts regarding aboriginal hockey players

Posted December 30, 2017

Viewed 7051 times

Fred Sasakamoose is honoured at the Edmonton Oilers and Chicago Blackhawks game in Edmonton. (Photo: THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jason Franson)
Fred Sasakamoose is honoured at the Edmonton Oilers and Chicago Blackhawks game in Edmonton. (Photo: THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jason Franson)

On December 29, 2017, Fred Sasakamoose was made a member to the Order of Canada, one of the highest honours for merit in the country.

Later that day, he was honoured at a special ceremony in Edmonton, and dropped the ceremonial face-off puck before a game between the Edmonton Oilers and Chicago Blackhawks.

Headlines and stories abounded with titles such as “Edmonton ceremony honours Order of Canada appointment for Fred Sasakamoose, first Indigenous NHL player” and “William Shatner, Jann Arden, first Indigenous NHL player among 125 appointments to Order of Canada”. One article even went so far to state that he was “the first indigenous pro hockey player.”

Sorry to put a damper on the celebrations, but Fred wasn’t the first to skate in the NHL, and was most certainly not the first professional indigenous player.

While only the selection committee knows which factors about Mr. Sasakamoose’s life and contributions to society were considered in the appointment, it goes without saying that the belief that he was the first indigenous player in the National Hockey League stands out among them.

Fred’s story has been well documented over the years in books, newspaper articles and documentaries, so I won’t expand on that now, other than to say that he appeared in 11 games for the Chicago Blackhawks in the 1953–54 season, and decided to leave professional hockey to return home.

So Who Was First?

Like most “first” questions, it is difficult to answer conclusively.

The first indigenous player in the NHL was likely Henry “Buddy” Maracle, who played 11 regular season games and 4 playoff games with the 1930–31 New York Rangers.

Henry Maracle
Henry Maracle

Maracle was born on September 08, 1904, in Ayr, Ontario, roughly 50 kilometres from the Six Nations Indian Reserve. His native ancestry is hard to dispute; contemporary newspaper accounts following his debut against the Detroit Falcons—despicable as some were—had titles like “Indian Wins Spurs with Hockey Club” and “Redskin Icer”, which went on to read “…is the only full-blooded redskin to reach professional hockey’s major league.”

A Question of Status?

It should be noted that Fred Sasakamoose’s distinction of being the first indigenous NHL player is often accompanied by the caveat “with treaty status”, as can be seen on his Wikipedia profile.

This was the same argument used by the CBC Trailbreakers documentary producer when I pointed out Maracle to them in 2012.

My efforts to determine if Henry Maracle was considered of “status” were met with the expected privacy concern responses by the department of Indigenous and Northern Affairs Canada (now Indigenous Services Canada), and ended as soon as they started.

I contacted a noted local indigenous CBC reporter who said “status doesn’t define us.” I agree. But he showed no interest in pursuing Maracle’s story. Same thing with the Institute of Canadian and Aboriginal Studies at the University of Ottawa, who I had asked for help in determining Henry’s status.

First Pro?

This piece wouldn’t be complete without mentioning Paul Jacobs.

Jacobs grew up on the Kahnawake Territory. He played professional hockey as early as 1912, and would go on to play in Montreal, Toronto, Quebec, New Haven and Cleveland.

Paul was a noted lacrosse player, and was playing for the Leaside Indians in Toronto in the summer of 1918. The Ontario Lacrosse Association’s president, Charlie Querrie, who was also the General Manager of the Toronto Arena NHL team (loosely the Maple Leafs ancestor club), invited Jacobs to attend the Arenas training camp, which Jacobs accepted on December 10, 1918.

Reports in the Toronto Telegram and the The Globe said Jacobs “Shows Good Form” and “…combined nicely with Noble and Denneny for several clever goals.” at training camp. On the day before the season opener for the Arena team against the Montreal Canadiens, the Toronto papers printed the proposed team roster, and Jacobs had earned himself a spot alongside many who would become legends.

The Arenas lost their season opener by a score of 4 to 3. However, newspaper reports and game summaries the following day did not show Jacobs in the lineup. In fact, The Globe had a tiny mention in the “Puckerings” section of the sports page which read as follows: “Paul Jacobs, the Leaside Indians defence player, who has been trying out with the Toronto Arenas, will not be available this season. He is leaving for Montreal to-night and will reside in that city in future.”

Parting Thoughts

Fred Sasakamoose deserves to be celebrated, and this piece is in no way intended to disrespect him or his accomplishments.

But it also demonstrates that more research must be done, and that the media and institutions have a responsibility to not simply perpetuate common misconceptions.

Does status matter? Does the percentage of indigenousness matter?

Given modern interpretations by the federal government and Supreme Court rulings, I would said that the answer is a resounding “No”.

So what about Henry?

Viewed 7051 times

Go to top

Moto-Hockey Comes to St. Louis
Posted March 30, 2018

Sorry Fred, but Henry came first - A few facts regarding aboriginal hockey players
Posted December 30, 2017

A Sporting Life; A closer look at the life of Jim Riley
Posted July 21, 2017

Well, you found me. Congratulations!
Posted October 15, 2016

Grandpa Played Pro Hockey (or so he said)
Posted November 15, 2015

About Losthockey

Between 1999 and 2003, I operated a website called losthockey.com where I posted profiles of obscure NHL players.

In the days before online databases, newspapers and vital records, I spent hours digging through microfilm, cold calling, and mailing letters in the hopes of uncovering leads. Sometimes I would get lucky and locate family members who were willing to share their relative's story.

Like all things on the internet, my work was appropriated and reproduced on websites such as findagrave.com (especially by this person) and in books, often verbatim, always uncredited.

So I have decided to reclaim my work by posting the profiles here, but with extra context detailing the process I followed. Enjoy!